How wealth data appends can dramatically improve lifetime value

I’ve worked with dozens of nonprofits of all shapes and sizes in various capacities over my career. Everyone from small local nonprofits providing services addressing homelessness to private universities to global nonprofits that operate on every continent (ok…so not Antarctica); smaller organizations with $500k annual budgets to massive organizations flirting with $1 billion in annual support.

Some nonprofits are more efficient at fundraising than others. And by efficient, I don’t mean they have the best ROI or raise the most on an annual basis. I mean they aren’t “leaving money on the table.” (In case you’re curious: most efficient doesn’t necessarily mean the highest budget.) What I really mean by “more efficient” is how well they’re able to connect with their supporters to inspire them to give at their maximum potential.

I’ve pounded this into your brain here on the Virtuous blog a million times: knowing your donor should be priority numero uno. It’s the foundation upon which all communication is built. If you don’t know who you’re speaking to, how do you know what to say or ask for?

One of the things I haven’t yet touched on is using wealth data overlays as one possible way to “know” your givers. For those unfamiliar with wealth data overlays: first, check out DonorSearch… they’re amazing and Virtuous has a direct integration with their web services (BONUS POINTS!); and second, think of it as a way to get financial metrics on your current or potential supporters like: household income, total assets, real estate value metrics, age, and other organizations they support (and at what levels). The list goes on and on.

Let’s take a look at two totally real organizations that are in no way fake: and Both receive a generous $50 gift from Mrs. Jane Peabody. But that is where the similarities of their relationship with Jane ends.

  • immediately sends a really well-crafted and timely “thank you” receipt; immediately appends wealth data after receiving Jane’s $50 gift, sees that she typically gives $1,000 to similar organizations and sends a handwritten “thank you” notecard with a personal message about how her gift will impact the organization’s mission.
  • Because they use best practices, drops Jane in their normal direct mail/email communication stream asking for a $35 gift each month based upon her RFM score. drops Jane into a Potential Major Donor communication stream. She receives monthly communications about the organization’s impact and what supporters’ contributions accomplish. She also receives a personal phone call from a Donor Rep ten days after her first donation. The two talk about why Jane gave and what she’s passionate about.
  • Over the next year, gets three more $35 gifts from Jane as part of their normal donor communication plan. Four total gifts with a life-to-date total of $155 in just 12 months… not too shabby. During the same time period, received one $500 and one $1,000 gift from targeted major donor development mailings, and a commitment from Jane to give $3,000 in the coming year.

If I were the Director of Development at, I’d feel pretty dang proud (and I should!). I’d thank my team for all their hard work and would probably get a pat on the back myself. I followed all the industry best practices to a T and it paid off. Just look at the results: a generous new giver with four gifts in the first year! No nonprofit on the planet would NOT want a new giver like Jane.

But obviously, when you take a closer look at the data and do a quick compare and contrast between the and, the results start to look a little lack-luster.

If the giving levels outlined above hold true over the next 5 years, Jane will have a lifetime value of $755 with and $12,650 with With the wealth data overlays, also has the insights and opportunity to put Jane in touch with their Director of Gift Planning for a potential bequest from Jane’s estate. Same person, but two dramatically different experiences and results. Because used data appends and scoring to understand Jane from the get go, her impact and connection to them resulted in nearly a 17x LTV.

To learn more about wealth data appends, check out DonorSearch. I promise you’ll like what you see!

Raisers Edge and Virtuous demo

Fundraising insights you won’t delete.
Delivered to your inbox weekly.
See The Big Picture: Nonprofit Technology Ecosystem Mapping

See The Big Picture: Nonprofit Technology Ecosystem Mapping

If you’re thinking about making a technology change or even simply want to use your existing technology better, there’s one thing you need to do before you take action. Is…
5 Tips For Better Change Management 

5 Tips For Better Change Management 

A lot of nonprofit folks are hesitant to change technology, but it’s not for the reasons you think. It’s not because they love their current systems. It’s not because they…

Grow generosity with Virtuous.

Virtuous is the responsive fundraising software platform proven to help nonprofit organizations increase generosity by serving all donors personally, no matter their gift size.

“Virtuous truly understands nonprofits and the importance of our mission. And their open access to data and built-in custom reports gave us access to the data we need.”
Todd Shinabarger​
Chief Information Officer