Contents

Virtuous Insights: Targeting Donors Most Likely to Give

TL;DR:

  • Virtuous Insights provides giving, engagement, third-party data, and machine-learning prediction scores all in one place
  • The Likelihood Score blends all of the giving, engagement, wealth, and third-party data “signals” into a single 0–100 score for every contact, trained on over 50 million donor histories
  • Use it for active donor retention, lapsed donor reactivation, and new donor acquisition
  • It hands you a shorter, more honest list of names so you can spend your day building real, lasting relationships with the people who make your mission possible

When Data Feels Like a Barrier Rather Than a Bridge

Having served as a fundraiser in the nonprofit and agency space – I’ve felt the weight of analyzing data for hundreds, thousands, and even hundreds of thousands of donors to answer one question, “Who do we target?”

I know that for many of us in fundraising, data feels like a barrier rather than a bridge. We want to spend our time building authentic connections with donors, not buried in spreadsheets, reports, and dashboards. 

That’s why we built Virtuous Insights, a product that provides giving, engagement, third-party data, and machine-learning prediction scores all in one place. It clears the “admin fog” from your calendar and hands you a shorter, more honest list of names so you can spend your day building real, lasting relationships with the people who make your mission possible.

The Likelihood Score

One of the core features of Insights is the Likelihood Score. This machine-learning derived score blends all of the giving, engagement, wealth, and third-party data “signals” into a single 0–100 score for every contact. It’s a 360-degree view of donor readiness, trained on over 50 million donor histories. It is a way to make sure your most passionate supporters never fall through the cracks. 

3 Ways to Use the Likelihood Score

Virtuous Insights built predictive models that blend 1,000+ signals per donor with over 50M+ donor histories into one number per donor – providing full clarity into who to acquire, retain, and reactivate.

We analyzed our models against real past performance data, and here are the outcomes:

1. Donor Retention

Based on our analysis, you can see a 1.7X retention lift using Virtuous Insights.

By targeting donors who have low Likelihood Scores you can help retain your “quietly slipping” or pre-lapsed donors. Catching them with a thank-you engagement before they lapse is the most cost-effective way to grow your revenue. 

2. Lapsed Donor Reactivation

With the power of Virtuous Insights, you can 5.8X your Lapsed Reactivation.

Stop wasting your marketing budget on the entire lapsed file. Use Insights to identify those who are most likely to reactivate. It’s a surgical approach that honors your budget and time. 

3. Donor Acquisition

Our models have the power to 2x New Donor Acquisition.

Insights can even score non-donor contacts who haven’t given yet. You can focus your energy on the people in your database who are most likely to give their first gift. 

Your Mission Deserves Your Best Focus

At the end of the day, no software can replace the heart of a fundraiser. Data can’t sit across a coffee table and listen to a donor’s “why,” and it can’t share the joy of a life changed by your mission.

But what Virtuous Insights can do is provide best-in-class predictions to answer the question “Who do I target?”

Ready to see the Likelihood Score in action for your own organization?: Learn more about adding Virtuous Insights to your account.

author avatar
Cassandra Johnson

Cassandra is dedicated to building purpose-driven, data-inspired solutions that give fundraisers clear insights and effortless decision-making power. At Virtuous, she helps organizations unlock 360-degree donor views, analyze file performance, and leverage AI/ML predictive scoring. With past experience as a Vice President of Data and Analytics at a fundraising and marketing agency and a Development Director for a local nonprofit, Cassandra has guided fundraising strategies for organizations with budgets ranging from $150K to $300M.

What you should do now

Below are three ways we can help you begin your journey to building more personalized fundraising with responsive technology.

See the Virtuous platform in action.  Schedule a call with our team for personalized answers and expert advice on transforming your nonprofit with donor management software.

Download our free Responsive Maturity Model and learn the 5 steps to more personalized donor experiences.

If you know another nonprofit pro who’d enjoy reading this page, share it with them via Email, Linkedin, Twitter, or Facebook.

The Responsive Maturity Model
5 Steps to More Personalized Donor Experiences
Get Responsive Fundraising Tips
Get updates delivered directly to your inbox.

Summarize with AI

Giving USA 2026: How to Turn the Data Into Your Next Move

Giving USA 2026: How to Turn the Data Into Your Next Move

There’s a story in every study, data set, and list of numbers. And as a former fundraiser and the current Fundraiser in Residence at Virtuous, one of my favorite pastimes…
5 Top Themes From the 2026 Rescue Mission Benchmark Report

5 Top Themes From the 2026 Rescue Mission Benchmark Report

TL;DR Revenue has grown to ~117% of 2021 levels. Donor files haven’t. The sector is generating more from fewer donors, which creates fragility underneath stable revenue. Second-gift conversion and second-year…
How to Use The 2026 Virtuous Benchmark Report for Human Services Nonprofits

How to Use The 2026 Virtuous Benchmark Report for Human Services Nonprofits

TL;DR Human Services had a quietly strong year. Several metrics moved in the right direction at once, with median gift, average gift, gift frequency, and donor expansion all improving year…

Grow generosity with Virtuous

Virtuous is the responsive fundraising software platform proven to help nonprofit organizations increase generosity by serving all donors personally, no matter their gift size.

“Virtuous truly understands nonprofits and the importance of our mission. And their open access to data and built-in custom reports gave us access to the data we need.”
Todd Shinabarger​
Chief Information Officer