Contents

The Most Important Day of Giving Season Is the Day After Giving Tuesday

TL;DR:

  • Only 18.9 percent of first-time donors give again. [1]
  • Giving Tuesday donors repeat at 65 percent, against 52 percent for other donors. [2]
  • New donors often hear nothing for two weeks.
  • Plan the day after Giving Tuesday first.
  • AI drafts and surfaces. A human makes the call.

This past Sunday, AFP chapters across the country filled ballrooms for National Philanthropy Day, which turned forty this year. This day exists because a tax attorney in Orange County, California, decided it should. 

In the early 1980s, Doug Freeman drove one of President Reagan’s advisers to the airport after a philanthropy event, was asked whether Washington could help with anything, and said yes: a day to honor the people who give. 

By his own count, he made more than forty trips to Washington over the next several years to walk the idea through congressional offices, and by the time Reagan signed the proclamation in November 1986, forty years ago this month, there were organizing committees in forty states. Doug turned eighty this month, two days before the day he built.

I know Doug. Orange County was my home for 30 years, and I had the honor to learn from him during my years as a fundraiser. He is among the most generous people I have known. 

The proclamation took a signature; the day took a working attorney four years of flights to Washington, because he believed the people who give deserved a day that was about them rather than about the ask. Every November, fundraisers in Orange County and across the country still gather in ballrooms to honor the people who give. But the room has changed since 1986.

When Brian Crimmins, Michael Ashley, and I wrote The Generosity Crisis, we built the book around one number. At the turn of the century, two-thirds of American households gave to charity in a given year. 

By 2018, according to the Indiana University Lilly Family School of Philanthropy, the research team behind Giving USA, fewer than half did, and the share has slipped further since. Total dollars keep rising because the people still giving, gave more. The number of people giving keeps falling. We now honor philanthropy on a day when giving has become a minority behavior in America for the first time in our history.

Our argument in the book was that this is not primarily a wealth problem or a tax problem or a generational problem, although each plays a part. 

It is a connection problem. 

People stop giving when no one at the organization seems to know they exist. This is the Great Donor Ignore, and it is not the nonprofit’s fault: donors tell you what they care about every day, and the systems built to hear them never could. Whether they recognize it or not, nonprofits are competing for connection rather than for dollars.

The data since has only hardened that view. The Fundraising Effectiveness Project’s full-year 2025 report put first-time donor retention at 18.9 percent, fewer than one in five, and the FEP now calls the gap between a first gift and a second “the most consequential unsolved problem in the donor pipeline.” [1] 

Which brings us to the Tuesday after Thanksgiving. Giving Tuesday 2025 raised $4 billion in the United States, 13 percent more than the year before, with 19.1 million people making a financial gift. The day works. 

Research from the GivingTuesday Data Commons shows that donors who give on Giving Tuesday repeat at a higher rate than donors who give at other times of year, about 65 percent against 52 percent for donors overall. [2] 

The trap is not the day. The trap is what happens on the day after. 

Giving Tuesday is run as a campaign: a thermometer, a match, a countdown, a final email at 11 p.m. Then, the thermometer comes down, and the thank-you goes out as a receipt. The new donor hears nothing for two weeks, and then hears the year-end appeal, which asks again before anyone has acknowledged what they did or wondered why they did it. 

A first gift is a question the donor is asking: is this a place that will notice me? 

Most of our December calendars answer no.

A first gift is a question the donor is asking: is this a place that will notice me?

At Virtuous, we have had an answer to the Great Donor Ignore since long before AI entered the conversation. Responsive fundraising means listening, connecting, suggesting, and learning in that order, and Giving Tuesday is where the order matters most. 

A responsive Giving Tuesday thanks the donor within minutes, in language that names what they gave to and not only how much. 

It listens: which story did they read before they gave, which fund did they choose, did they arrive through a friend’s share or through the match. Then, it follows up on what the donor cared about rather than on what the organization wants to say next. Someone who gave to the food pantry after reading about one family should hear how that family is doing in January, not receive the capital campaign appeal in December. 

Stewardship for a new giver is personalization at its most basic: proof that someone noticed.

This is where AI earns its place, and where it has to stay in its place. The reason first-time donors go unthanked and unheard is rarely indifference. It is arithmetic. A development office of three people cannot write a personal note to 1,400 December donors, read what each one clicked, and decide who warrants a phone call. The tools we build at Virtuous are aimed at that gap. 

  • Automation in Virtuous CRM+ connects the gift to the follow-up, so the thank-you reflects the donor’s actual path to the form and goes out while the gift is still fresh. 
  • Virtuous Insights rescores every record daily, so when a $50 Giving Tuesday donor opens the impact story three times and lingers on the planned giving page, the team knows by Thursday instead of discovering it in a year-end report.
  • Virtuous Momentum takes those signals and puts a drafted, personal next step in front of a gift officer, so the human conversation happens with the dozen new donors who warrant it and not only with the twenty the officer already knew.

None of this removes the person. 

The AI drafts, assigns, and surfaces; a human decides who gets the call and makes it. The donor is owed a relationship with an organization, not with a model, and a thank-you that reads as machine-written is worse than a late one, because it tells the donor what kind of relationship this is going to be.

Before you write a single Giving Tuesday email, decide what a new donor will hear the day after. Write the welcome series now: the thank-you, a story from the program they gave to, and one message that asks them something rather than tells them something. Then tag the campaign, the forms, and the stories so that every gift arrives with its source attached. You cannot follow up on what a donor cares about if the system never recorded it.

Our GivingTuesday Playbook has a suggested structure for a post-gift automation workflow. Plus, frameworks for reporting results, debriefing with teams, and planning next year’s improvements.

During the actual day, let the donation page carry the signal. Offer the fund, the story, and the referral as choices. Hold the generic receipt, and send the thank-you that names what they gave to, inside the hour if your system can manage it.

After, treat the first two weeks of December as stewardship season rather than appeal season. Make the human calls. Write the personal notes. A board member or gift officer phoning even a few dozen new donors to say thank you with no ask attached is still the highest-value hour of the season, and the data can now tell you which few dozen. When the year-end appeal goes out in late December, send new donors a version that acknowledges they already gave this month. And in January, report back on the thing they gave to, by name.

All of that is the oldest advice in fundraising: thank people personally and follow up on what they care about. What is new is the premium on it. As the world grows more synthetic and more atomized, with more of what reaches a donor generated rather than written and more of daily life lived alone in front of a screen, the personal touch is becoming scarce, and scarce things carry a premium. The note that could only have come from someone who noticed is the number one way your organization will stand out next year, ahead of any campaign, any platform, or any match.

National Philanthropy Day honors the people who give. Giving Tuesday provides the energy to take action. The most useful way to honor donors this year is to treat their first gift as the beginning of something rather than the end of a campaign. 

The generosity crisis will not be solved on a Tuesday. It might be eased on a Wednesday, when the person who gave $50 for the first time hears, by name, that it mattered, and hears about it again in January. If we are competing for connection, December is when most of the year’s new relationships will begin. Decide now whether they will be relationships or receipts.

FAQs

Why Is the Day After Giving Tuesday So Important?

A first gift is a question the donor is asking: is this a place that will notice me? When the thank-you goes out as a receipt and the next message is a year-end appeal, the answer is no.

What Is the Great Donor Ignore?

It’s what happens when donors tell you what they care about every day and the systems built to hear them can’t. It is not the nonprofit’s fault, but it has been a reality for many.

How Many First-Time Donors Give a Second Gift?

The Fundraising Effectiveness Project’s 2025 data put first-time donor retention at 18.9 percent, fewer than one in five. [1]

Do Giving Tuesday Donors Give Again?

Yes, at a higher rate. Donors who give on Giving Tuesday repeat at about 65 percent, against 52 percent for other donors. [2]

What Should Nonprofits Do the Day After Giving Tuesday?

Treat the first two weeks of December as stewardship season. Make personal calls, write personal notes, and report back in January on the thing each donor gave to.

How Can AI Help With Donor Follow-Up?

AI can draft the thank-you, surface which new donors showed interest, and put a personal next step in front of a gift officer. A human still decides who gets the call and makes it.

author avatar
Nathan Chappell

Nathan is a leading expert at the intersection of Artificial Intelligence and philanthropy, serving as a Chief AI officer at Virtuous. He has led AI deployments for some of the nation’s largest nonprofits and founded Fundraising.Ai, a collaborative initiative focused on data ethics, privacy, and sustainability. Nathan’s insights have been featured in Fast Company, University of Notre Dame, and AHP. A Forbes Technology Council member, he holds advanced degrees from Notre Dame, Redlands, Cambridge, and MIT.

The Responsive Maturity Model
5 Steps to More Personalized Donor Experiences
Get Responsive Fundraising Tips
Get updates delivered directly to your inbox.

Summarize with AI

How Nonprofits Can Use the Emerging Trend of Giving Circles to Augment Their Fundraising

How Nonprofits Can Use the Emerging Trend of Giving Circles to Augment Their Fundraising

TL;DR Giving Circles are groups of people who pool their money, learn together, and decide as a group where to give. Nearly 4,000 groups moved more than $3.1…
How to Evaluate and Design Your Nonprofit Tech Ecosystem

How to Evaluate and Design Your Nonprofit Tech Ecosystem

Start with discovery, not demos. Get clear on your goals, problems, and stakeholders before you look at any software. Integrations come in different shapes. Decide which data needs…
8 Helpful Giving Tuesday Email Examples to Inspire Your Campaign

8 Helpful Giving Tuesday Email Examples to Inspire Your Campaign

End-of-year bustle doesn’t always lend itself to getting creative in fundraising campaigns. But when Giving Tuesday rolls around, sending out the same copy/pasted emails from last year just…

Grow generosity with Virtuous

Virtuous is the responsive fundraising software platform proven to help nonprofit organizations increase generosity by serving all donors personally, no matter their gift size.

“Virtuous truly understands nonprofits and the importance of our mission. And their open access to data and built-in custom reports gave us access to the data we need.”
Todd Shinabarger​
Chief Information Officer