Contents

How to Use AI in Major Gifts and Keep Relationships Human

TL;DR:

  • Find Prospects: Use AI to look beyond wealth and identify connections to your mission.
  • Capture Conversations: Put meeting notes in your CRM so AI has useful information to work with.
  • Keep People Involved: Let AI support follow-up while fundraisers lead conversations and decisions.
  • Start Small: Test a focused use with willing gift officers before expanding.

Major gift fundraising takes time with people. Yet the work around those relationships can easily swallow your day of fundraising: researching prospects, updating records, deciding who to contact, and preparing follow-up.

AI can help with that work.

But the question is where to use it so your team has more room to listen, learn what donors care about, and build trust.

On the Responsive Lab podcast, Scott Holthaus talked with Randall Hallett, CEO and founder of Hallett Philanthropy, about using AI in major gifts without losing the personal relationships that make the work matter.

“The miracle that you’re looking for doesn’t exist. The help that you need does,” Randall said.

AI can help a gift officer make sense of information and think through what to do next. The fundraiser still has to make the call, have the meeting, and understand what the donor wants to accomplish.

Watch the conversation below:

7 Ways to Use AI in Major Gifts and Keep Relationships Human

1. Look for Mission Connection Alongside Giving Capacity

A list of wealthy people gives your team a place to start researching. It doesn’t tell you who wants to support your work.

Major gift prospect identification needs to consider both philanthropic interest and a connection to your mission. Someone’s ability to give is only part of the picture. Their experiences, interests, and history with your organization matter too.

AI can help analyze information that would take a team more time than it has to review by hand. Used well, that analysis can surface people worth getting to know, including prospects who don’t look like your picture of a major donor. Virtuous Insights, for example, combines your CRM data with wealth, demographic, and engagement signals to score every contact, so your team starts with a ranked list instead of a blank spreadsheet.

Use those findings to decide where a conversation could be worthwhile. Then listen. The point of identifying a prospect is to find out whether your mission connects with something they want to make possible.

2. Give Each Portfolio Enough Attention to Build Relationships

A large portfolio can feel reassuring. There’s always another name to contact, and cutting someone can feel like giving up on a future gift.

But names alone don’t build relationships. A portfolio needs people a gift officer can realistically engage and cultivate.

Use data to examine who belongs in active major gift cultivation. Ask whether there’s a reasonable path to a gift now, in the near future, or over a longer stretch with the right conversations.

That also means being willing to move people out of a portfolio when they don’t qualify for that level of attention. They can keep receiving annual giving communications, and a later change in their giving or engagement may be a reason to revisit the relationship.

For leaders, asking gift officers to release names takes trust. Show how the identification process can refill a portfolio with promising prospects. It’s easier to focus when the team believes other people worth getting to know are coming.

3. Put What You Learn Into Your CRM

Picture leaving a donor meeting after learning about a cause they care deeply about. What you just learned could shape your next conversation. If it stays in your head, though, it can’t inform the recommendations your technology gives you.

AI needs the relationship information your team collects. Previous meetings, giving history, timing, and the purposes a donor has supported all give it context for what might happen next.

Make capturing that information part of the meeting follow-up. Include what you learned about the donor’s interests and what’s still unclear.

Voice notes can make that easier. With Virtuous Momentum, a fundraiser can record a voice note after a meeting, have AI clean it up and summarize it, and automatically log it in the CRM.

The value starts with getting useful information into the record. Once it’s there, a conversation can inform future work instead of becoming one more detail someone has to remember.

4. Use AI Recommendations to Prepare Your Next Move

Once meeting notes are in the database, AI can help connect new information with what your organization already knows.

Depending on how your system is built, it may help a fundraiser think through:

  • Timing: When giving or contact history suggests it may be useful to reach out.
  • Missing Information: What you still need to learn about the donor’s interests.
  • Next Steps: Whether to continue learning, follow up, or consider an ask.

Treat those recommendations as guidance. Your experience and your knowledge of the relationship still decide how to proceed.

A suggested next step can help you prepare a more focused conversation. It can’t have that conversation for you or decide what the donor wants.

5. Make Stewardship Relevant to the Donor’s Interests

The information you collect during cultivation should keep shaping the relationship after a gift.

AI can help tailor your stewardship messages to the impact each donor cares about. That beats treating every supporter as if they gave for the same reason.

Connect the follow-up to what the donor wanted their gift to accomplish. The relationship context in your CRM can help shape that message.

Keep a clear line between preparing an update and having a conversation. When a donor responds with questions, concerns, or new interests, a person needs to listen and engage.

That holds across all of major gift work, with technology supporting the communication and people staying responsible for the relationship.

6. Build Team Confidence Through a Small Pilot

A team can see the appeal of AI and still hesitate to change how it works day to day.

Start with one or two gift officers who are willing to try a focused change. That could mean using AI to support prospect identification or making meeting documentation easier.

Give the pilot clear boundaries. Explain what the team will try, why it matters, and which decisions stay with the fundraiser.

Then let colleagues see the process in practice. A concrete example gives people something to assess and discuss. Visiting a team that already works this way can also help people picture it.

Trust grows when people can see how a change helps them do their jobs. You don’t need to overhaul the whole major gift program at once.

7. Protect the Time AI Helps You Recover

When administrative work gets easier, you have a chance to spend more time with donors. Your team still has to protect that time.

Look at what else competes for a major gift officer’s attention. Large galas and golf tournaments can pull fundraisers into event work that takes them away from their portfolios. Small gatherings designed to introduce prospective donors serve a different purpose, so think about what each activity actually contributes to relationship building.

Use the time you recover for calls, meetings, and follow-up that shows you listened. Major gift work still requires understanding what someone hopes to accomplish and helping them explore how your organization can make that possible.

Start with one part of the process that slows your team down. Test how AI can help, keep the relationship decisions with people, and use the extra room to give donors more attention.

See how Momentum fits your team

Momentum drafts outreach in each gift officer’s voice, builds a plan for every donor, and syncs the activity back to your CRM. Your team reviews and sends every message. If that’s the kind of help your gift officers need, schedule a Momentum demo.

FAQs

1. How Can AI Help With Major Gift Fundraising?

AI can help with major gift fundraising by supporting prospect identification, meeting documentation, follow-up recommendations, and tailored stewardship communications. Fundraisers stay responsible for conversations, relationship building, and decisions.

2. Can AI Replace a Major Gift Officer?

AI can’t take over the trust building and personal conversations at the center of a major gift officer’s work. It can help a fundraiser organize information and consider next steps while the fundraiser leads the relationship.

3. What Donor Data Does AI Need for Major Gift Work?

AI needs relevant donor information in your database, including meeting notes, giving history, supported causes, and known interests. That context helps a system connect new information with the existing relationship.

4. How Can a Major Gift Team Start Using AI?

A major gift team can start using AI through a focused pilot with one or two willing gift officers. Clear boundaries and chances to see the process in practice can help the broader team build confidence.

author avatar
Matt Roseti
Matt is the Organic Search & Content Manager at Virtuous. As a content writer, some of his favorite niches are nonprofits, tech, physical health, and exercise. He also coaches and edits for other copywriters and SEO/AEO Specialists. When not writing, you'll find him enjoying an Americano on his front porch or closely investigating all the tide pools with his wife and daughter at the beach.
The Responsive Maturity Model
5 Steps to More Personalized Donor Experiences
Get Responsive Fundraising Tips
Get updates delivered directly to your inbox.

Summarize with AI

How Nonprofits Can Use the Emerging Trend of Giving Circles to Augment Their Fundraising

How Nonprofits Can Use the Emerging Trend of Giving Circles to Augment Their Fundraising

TL;DR Giving Circles are groups of people who pool their money, learn together, and decide as a group where to give. Nearly 4,000 groups moved more than $3.1…
8 Helpful Giving Tuesday Email Examples to Inspire Your Campaign

8 Helpful Giving Tuesday Email Examples to Inspire Your Campaign

End-of-year bustle doesn’t always lend itself to getting creative in fundraising campaigns. But when Giving Tuesday rolls around, sending out the same copy/pasted emails from last year just…
What to Expect: Everything You Need to Know About Migrating to Virtuous CRM+

What to Expect: Everything You Need to Know About Migrating to Virtuous CRM+

TL;DR We focus on data migration (moving your data) and configuration (getting your platform set up to run for your org). Migration has three phases: review, mapping, and…

Grow generosity with Virtuous

Virtuous is the responsive fundraising software platform proven to help nonprofit organizations increase generosity by serving all donors personally, no matter their gift size.

“Virtuous truly understands nonprofits and the importance of our mission. And their open access to data and built-in custom reports gave us access to the data we need.”
Todd Shinabarger​
Chief Information Officer