The 8 Reasons Why Nonprofits Measure Impact

Today’s nonprofits must be responsive, agile, and data-driven to fulfill their mission. In the modern era of philanthropy, donors are not merely looking to support organizations. They are seeking to make an impact. At the heart of this evolution lies the pressing need for nonprofits to measure impact and share with donors how their dollars fuel outcomes.

But why is it so vital? On the Responsive Nonprofit Podcast, John Mark Vanderpool, Co-Founder of Social Impact Solutions, discussed the importance of impact data, how to measure it, and the power of translating data into transformative stories of impact and positive outcomes.

Listen to the episode below or on your favorite station including Spotify and Apple Podcasts.

What Donors Look For When You Measure Impact

Today’s philanthropic scene is characterized by a palpable shift in donor behavior and expectations. Donors now see themselves as pivotal change makers. This perspective isn’t born out of mere generosity but a deeper desire to instigate tangible, positive impact.

John Mark Vanderpool quote on how to measure impact

Here’s a comprehensive look at what modern donors seek:

  • Partnership in Change: Donors no longer want to be passive contributors. They aim to align themselves with nonprofits and social enterprises that share their vision. In these organizations, they don’t see themselves as mere beneficiaries but as partners in catalyzing change.
  • Understanding Impact: The term “impact” might seem nebulous to some, but in the context of nonprofits, it refers to both the short-term and long-term outcomes of the organization’s programs. Donors aspire to discern this change, quantified across different timelines—short, midterm, and long-term (from one year to five years or more).
  • Transparency is Paramount: Modern donors, including major givers and the younger demographic like millennials and Gen Z, heavily prioritize transparency. A staggering 97% of major donors point out that their primary reason for contributing is understanding an organization’s impact. The absence of this clarity can even deter them from supporting a cause, regardless of its merit.
  • Stories of Transformation: While hard data offers credibility, donors also crave narratives that touch their hearts. Giving is deeply personal. They desire stories of transformation, genuine accounts of how their contributions have reshaped lives or communities.
  • Position in the Ecosystem: One often overlooked aspect is making donors realize their place in the grand scheme of things, and how their contributions shape the overarching ecosystem of the nonprofit. Help donors visualize the world the organization seeks to create, and where they fit in that vision.

Nonprofit organizations must strive for data-driven stories of transformation while constantly reinforcing how crucial donors are in realizing the collective mission. The underlying thread tying all these elements together is transparency. John Mark Vanderpool mentions, “We can’t market without measurements.” Transparency doesn’t dilute an organization’s strategy; it amplifies it, unlocking newer avenues of giving. 

Effective programs and their impact have a holistic ripple effect across nonprofit organizations. It’s not confined to finance, accounting, or even marketing and development. Instead, the heartbeat of impact pulsates within the operations department. An essential caveat is the interconnected reliance of marketing, development, and finance on impact data to fuel their roles effectively.

There is a logic model – a theory for change – that centers around charting the path from actions to their eventual societal consequences. This can be fragmented into four significant segments:

  1. Inputs: Resources or investments that the program will utilize.
  2. Activities: Actions or strategies that use the inputs.
  3. Outputs: Direct, tangible products or results of the activities.
  4. Outcomes: Longer-term changes, improvements, or benefits due to the program.

The benefit of when you measure impact is how we translate the data to outcomes. While outputs, such as the number of meals delivered or individuals served, are undeniably crucial, they merely depict a partial narrative.

Outcomes provide a panoramic perspective, tracking the transformative journey of beneficiaries and the program’s long-term effects on their lives. Sadly, the sector’s predominant trend has been an over-reliance on output metrics. This is attributed largely to a lack of sophisticated technological infrastructure within many organizations. Many rely on rudimentary tools like Excel spreadsheets, which offer limited insights. The golden opportunity now lies in leveraging technology to chronicle the holistic picture – encapsulating short-term, mid-term, and long-term program effects.

This not only answers funders’ inquiries but also aligns with the intrinsic motivations of employees, volunteers, and donors. Meticulously tracking individual beneficiary journeys, nonprofits could aggregate data, offering an expansive view of their impact.

In this new era of fundraising, responsive nonprofits are navigating through a paradigm shift – from transactional interactions that often see donors as mere financial reservoirs, to transformational partnerships. Responsive nonprofits engage donors as co-creators of change. Ultimately, data-driven outcomes from social impact metrics will deepen trust with donors and supporters, fueling deeper levels of giving and a sense of responsible investing in the nonprofits that can harness this data.

What is Impact Data?

Impact data is the collection of statistics, figures, and outcomes that showcase the change an organization has made in its area of focus. This data can be:

  • Short-term: Immediate results post an initiative.
  • Mid-term: Changes observed after a sustained period.
  • Long-term: The sustainable and long-lasting impact created over the years.
John Mark Vanderpool quote on how to measure impact

By having concrete data on hand, organizations can provide evidence of their effectiveness, making it a powerful tool in driving support and funding. 

How to Get Started with Data Collection and Measure Impact

When diving into data and its significance in social enterprises and non-profits, the primary question is how to begin. These steps will help guide you in how to collect, measure impact, and use data to foster positive change.

1. Begin with a Theory of Change:

  • Before diving into advanced data techniques, every organization must first outline its vision or mission. This is the foundation upon which other steps are built. It’s essentially stating the changes the organization aims to bring about.
  • This is the first level on the spectrum of impact developed by the Sorenson Impact Center at the University of Utah. The theory simply marks the intent without guaranteed outcomes.

2. Identify Key Performance Indicators (KPIs):

  • Once the mission is clear, organizations need to pinpoint measurable metrics. KPIs indicate what the organization is accomplishing in line with its mission.
  • This is level two, and it highlights the tangible outputs of the organization.

3. Track Outcomes with Surveys:

  • Beyond just outputs, non-profits need to understand the results of their efforts. Surveys, especially pre-post surveys, are an excellent method.
  • By measuring where beneficiaries are before the program and where they end up afterward, organizations can see tangible shifts in outcomes.

4. Delve into Academic Analysis:

  • As the organization matures, more intricate and thorough analyses come into play. Advanced levels, such as randomized control trials, involve partnerships with academic institutions.
  • Organizations like World Vision and the Bill and Linda Gates Foundation have harnessed this approach, using RCTs to deeply analyze their interventions.

5. Transparency and Responsiveness:

  • The fear of negative results often deters non-profits to measure impact. However, transparency is crucial. Donors respect efforts and the commitment to change, even if the initial results aren’t all positive.
  • Organizations should use data not just for impact reports, but also to make improvements. If a strategy isn’t working, data will spotlight this, allowing organizations to pivot and adapt.

6. Case Study: VisionSpring:

  • Even reputable organizations encounter hurdles. VisionSpring, for instance, succeeded in India but faced challenges in Central and South America. They spent millions without desired outcomes.
  • However, their transparency and commitment to change garnered more support from their donors, proving that data-driven honesty and the will to adapt can lead to even stronger backing and improved strategies.

7. Embrace Continuous Learning:

  • The journey doesn’t end once an organization starts collecting and analyzing data. The aim should always be continuous improvement.
  • The worst scenario is stagnation. As in every facet of life, there’s an inherent need to evolve and adapt based on feedback and outcomes.

Leveraging data in their program design is paramount for nonprofits to demonstrate their impact, refine their strategies, and foster genuine change. Starting may seem daunting, but with a structured approach and the dedication to evolving, the rewards, both in terms of impact and support, can be immense. 

Translating Impact Data into Effective Messaging and Fundraising

In the intricate dance of marketing, fundraising, and understanding impact data lies the alchemy of successful donor engagement. Here’s how we turn data into a compelling narrative:

  1. Understanding Donors’ Desires: Donors are not just looking for a place to give money; they’re seeking stories of transformation and data-backed impacts. They wish to see how they fit into a theory of change.
  2. Engaging New Donors: Imagine a new donor entering your ecosystem. Your messaging should make clear the crucial role they play in propelling the cause forward. They want to see both past accomplishments (stories of transformation) and potential future impacts.
  3. Automated Personal Touch: Surprisingly, a simple ‘thank you’ can stand out. Utilizing email automation and a nonprofit CRM like Virtuous, one can consistently update donors with stories of transformation and future objectives. This keeps them informed, valued, and invested.
  4. Capturing Passion at the Right Time: Nonprofits miss opportunities when they fail to capture a donor’s excitement promptly. Immediate engagement helps donor feel seen and heard, and create a hyper-personal connection. 
  5. Personalized Engagement: Just as donors want to contribute to your mission’s transformation, they themselves seek transformation through their association with your mission. Their personal stories and transformations parallel the mission. Use this to build deeper relationships.
  6. Assessing Impact on Donors: Beyond measuring the direct impact of programs, consider the ripple effect on donors. How have their lives changed due to their association with your organization?
  7. Authenticity and Transparency: Today’s donors, especially millennials and Gen Z, crave authentic experiences. They don’t want sugar-coated stories; they want the real, raw truth.
  8. Harnessing the Power of Personalization: Current trends indicate that personalizing donor communications can substantially boost donor retention and giving rates. 
  9. Systems for Sustainable Growth: Adopting systems that foster such improvements should be a top priority for nonprofit leaders. The focus should be on increasing the donor’s lifetime value for sustainable growth.
John Mark Vanderpool quote on how to measure impact

Translating impact data into messaging is about knowing your audience, addressing them at the right moments, and ensuring that the communication is authentic and resonates with their personal journey. This is where long-term, meaningful relationships are nurtured along the donor journey. 

Successful donor engagement hinges on turning impact data into compelling narratives. Donors seek stories of transformation and measurable impacts, showing them where they fit in the journey of change. Engaging new donors requires showcasing past successes and potential future impacts, while timely and consistent updates, often through automation, enhance their sense of value and investment. Personalized engagement, emphasizing authenticity and transparency, resonates deeply with modern donors. With proper systems in place, organizations can see significant growth in donor retention and contributions, emphasizing the importance of increasing a donor’s lifetime value for sustained growth.

Listen to the episode below or on your favorite station including Spotify and Apple Podcasts.

Resources To Measure Impact

What you should do now

Below are three ways we can help you begin your journey to building more personalized fundraising with responsive technology.

See the Virtuous platform in action.  Schedule a call with our team for personalized answers and expert advice on transforming your nonprofit with donor management software.

Download our free Responsive Maturity Model and learn the 5 steps to more personalized donor experiences.

If you know another nonprofit pro who’d enjoy reading this page, share it with them via Email, Linkedin, Twitter, or Facebook.

The Responsive Maturity Model
5 Steps to More Personalized Donor Experiences
Get Responsive Fundraising Tips
Get updates delivered directly to your inbox.
Actionable tips and insights for personalizing donor engagement with responsive fundraising.
The Responsive Nonprofit: Practices that Drive Nonprofit Innovation

The Responsive Nonprofit: Practices that Drive Nonprofit Innovation

At The Responsive Nonprofit Summit, Virtuous CEO Gabe Cooper presented some key takeaways from his new book, The Responsive Nonprofit. The presentation highlighted the importance of innovation for nonprofits to…
Future Trends in AI Fundraising: What Nonprofits Need to Know

Future Trends in AI Fundraising: What Nonprofits Need to Know

Explore AI fundraising to boost donor engagement and campaign efficiency for your nonprofit. Learn innovative strategies for successful fundraising.
A Beginner's Guide To Nonprofit Grant Management

A Beginner's Guide To Nonprofit Grant Management

This guide simplifies grant management for nonprofits, covering how to identify, apply for, and manage grants to secure essential funding.

Grow generosity with Virtuous.

Virtuous is the responsive fundraising software platform proven to help nonprofit organizations increase generosity by serving all donors personally, no matter their gift size.

“Virtuous truly understands nonprofits and the importance of our mission. And their open access to data and built-in custom reports gave us access to the data we need.”
Todd Shinabarger
Chief Information Officer